The Pusher Moved Into Software
Why the Free First Hit Failed on the Street and Works in Games, Trials and Apps
Criminologists found that street sellers of controlled substances rarely give free samples to strangers because it makes no economic sense. Free-to-play games, loot boxes and card-required trials remove every constraint that made the tactic fail.
A capsule-toy machine outside a grocery store, a streaming trial that wants a card number before it shows you anything, a stranger at the school gate with a free sample in his pocket. Two of these are ordinary parts of modern life. The third is a story adults have told children for a hundred years, and the evidence says it almost never happened.
A clinician who treats gaming addiction made the case recently that free games cost their players the most, in money, in hours, and in whatever those hours were supposed to be for. The examples will be familiar to anyone who has watched a child play on a phone. Upgrades held behind a timer unless you pay to skip it. A shield that recharges only when you open the app. Events that expire if you do not play often enough. The old line holds that when something is free, you are the product. That fits advertising. It fits these games less well, and the reason runs through an unlikely field, the criminology of illicit markets.
The Pusher Was a Bad Businessman
The free first dose has a long paper trail. A New York newspaper warned in 1924 that peddlers handed out free doses to young people until they were hooked, and an authoritative book on addiction repeated the claim four years later. By 1941 the sociologist Alfred Lindesmith was pointing out that nobody had produced any evidence for it. The image outlived him, carried along by propaganda films in the 1930s, crime films in the 1970s and 1980s, pop songs and talk radio.
Between 2000 and 2001 the criminologist Ross Coomber interviewed 21 convicted sellers in a London prison and 60 long-term users at treatment centres, and asked them about freebies. Thirteen of the nineteen sellers whose answers he could use said they gave things away, nearly all of them to people they already knew and trusted. None used freebies to recruit someone who had never used. A quarter of the users had never been offered anything for free, and not one had been offered a sample by a seller who did not already know they used.
Nineteen Sellers, No Strangers
London street sellers asked whether they give out freebies, 2000 to 2001
src coomber 2003
The reasons are economic, and they are dull. Dependence, even on the most addictive substances, usually takes months, so a seller would have to subsidize a stranger for a long time before seeing a return. A child given something for free might tell someone, and the seller carries the arrest. A seller can also be jailed, robbed or out of the trade long before the investment pays back. In practice the freebie did smaller, more familiar work. It rewarded a regular, let a buyer test the strength, or kept a customer from drifting to a competitor. One seller in the study handed out the odd extra when he knew a client was buying elsewhere, which is the street version of the discount that appears when you click cancel.
Coomber also noticed where the myth had wandered. His paper reprints a joke comparing street sellers to software developers, with the pusher’s free first hit set beside a free trial download. Legal industries, meanwhile, ran the play in the open. Pharmaceutical companies gave samples to doctors, and the makers of one legal, habit-forming product handed out free packs to people who had never bought one. The predatory free sample existed all along. It belonged to firms that could not be arrested and planned to be around for decades.
What a Platform Changes
Take away the street seller’s constraints and the freebie starts to make sense. The researcher Isak Ladegaard tested this on Agora, an anonymous market for controlled substances that worked like an ordinary shopping site, with listings, ratings and reviews. Over 305 days in 2014 and 2015 he followed 2,116 vendors and found free or nearly free samples in every major product category.
The samples stayed small, never more than a little over three sales in a hundred. They tended to come from new vendors trying to get noticed, and vendors preferred to send them to buyers with a record of writing reviews, the market’s own critics. Vendors and regulars alike looked down on people who collected samples without buying. Only for prescription medicines, painkillers among them, did handing out samples lift later sales.
The Sample Was a Rounding Error
Free and low-cost sample sales as a share of other sales on Agora, 2014 to 2015
src ladegaard 2017
Data
| Category | Samples to other sales |
|---|---|
| Stimulants | 3.24% |
| Party pills | 2.08% |
| Herbal | 1.59% |
| Painkillers | 1.45% |
| Prescription | 1.14% |
| Hallucinogens | 0.85% |
Once the illicit trade borrowed the architecture of online retail, the free sample appeared, and it behaved like influencer marketing rather than the man at the school gate. Software removes the constraints that remained. A free copy costs close to nothing to hand over, nobody gets arrested, and the company expects to be around for years. It can also watch exactly who spends, when, and on what. What would a street seller have done with a ledger of every purchase?
Free-to-play games are built on that visibility. A study of freemium services by the marketing researchers Thomas Niemand, Robert Mai and Sascha Kraus cites typical conversion rates from free to paid of three to five percent. A small minority pays for everyone else, and a business arranged that way has every reason to find its heaviest spenders and keep them spending. The timers, the recharging shields and the expiring events are how it does that.
The old saying comes from advertising, where the user is what gets sold. In a free game most players never pay at all, and the money comes from the few who pay a great deal.
The player is less the product than the plan.
The Odds Inside the Box
The sharpest version of the model sells chance. A loot box is a paid, sealed reward whose contents you learn only after paying, and the form is older than the games. Capsule-toy machines, trading card packs and the blind-box figures sold in toy shops all run on the same pull. Inside a game, though, the next box is a tap away, with no walk back to the store and no pocket to empty.
The research is careful about what it can claim. A meta-analysis of fifteen studies found a small to moderate link between loot box spending and gambling symptoms, a correlation of about 0.26. A correlation could run either way. A study that followed 636 young gamers for six months got closer to direction. Among those who did not gamble at the start, spending on loot boxes predicted taking up gambling later. Spending on items bought outright did not, which points at the randomness rather than at spending in general.
Regulators have started to draw the same line. On 11 November 2026 the European Commission proposed a Digital Fairness Act that would require anyone selling paid random rewards to show what can be won and the odds of winning it, and to give people a working way to turn the feature off. Reports differ on how far its limits for minors go. The proposal names wheels of fortune and card packs alongside loot boxes. It is not yet law, and it goes next to the European Parliament and the member states.
The Trial That Wants a Card
Outside games, the free sample has settled into the trial that asks for a card. Signing up takes a minute, and leaving can take a phone call. Researchers who audited popular news sites in four countries found cancellation flows that made people call a representative or type out a phrase before they could go, and sign-up pages that did not make the recurring charge clear.
The legal scholars Jamie Luguri and Lior Strahilevitz measured how well this works. They showed 1,963 Americans an offer for a data-protection plan they had not asked for. Given a plain yes or no, 11.3 percent accepted. With mild obstacles placed in the way of declining, 25.8 percent did. Aggressive tactics pushed acceptance to 41.9 percent, but they left people angry enough that the researchers could measure it afterward. The mild version produced no such backlash.
A Little Pressure Goes a Long Way
Share of people who accepted an unwanted data-protection plan, by interface
src luguri & strahilevitz journal of legal analysis 2021
The interface that works best leans rather than shoves. The street seller who kept his regulars sweet with the odd extra would recognize the method, though he never had a cancel button to hide.
Building the Thing Yourself
Some of those hours have started to go elsewhere. Tools that write code on request now let people who are not professional programmers build small apps and games for an audience of one. I have noticed my own evenings drifting from other people’s games toward building small ones this way, and nothing made like that has a timer, a shield or a shop. A game made for yourself has nobody on the other side waiting for the three to five percent.
The catch arrives with the tool. These assistants are sold by subscription and by usage, and a session can stop at a limit halfway through a thought. Their interfaces also resemble the machines this essay has been describing. Two computer scientists at the University of British Columbia reviewed eight popular chatbots and named unpredictable responses as one of the patterns that may encourage compulsive use, along with replies that stream in word by word. They borrowed a term from gambling, the near miss, for answers that are almost good enough. Their study looked at design and measured no addiction, and it covered chatbots rather than coding tools. Still, code that almost works is a near miss with an error message attached, and the button that asks for another attempt sits roughly where the lever used to.
The price of these tools is printed on a plan page, which is more than a capsule machine ever offered. The odds of the next attempt are printed nowhere. The proposal in Brussels covers loot boxes, wheels of fortune and card packs. It does not mention the regenerate button.
Request an AI summary
Learn more about the ideas and references behind this note.
FAQ
- Do street sellers really give out free samples to get people hooked?
- Rarely, according to the research. Ross Coomber's 2003 interviews with 21 convicted sellers and 60 long-term users in London found that freebies went almost entirely to known, trusted customers, and no seller reported using them to recruit non-users. Dependence takes months, giving controlled substances to strangers risks arrest, and a seller may not stay in business long enough to recover the cost. On anonymous online markets free samples were more common, but went mostly to experienced buyers who wrote reviews.
- What is the EU doing about loot boxes?
- On 11 November 2026 the European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act. Its Article 15 would require traders offering paid random rewards to disclose what can be won and the odds, and to provide tools to switch the feature off, and reports describe added limits for minors. It is a proposal, not law, and goes next to the European Parliament and the Council.
Keywords
Defined Terms
- Loot box
- A paid, sealed reward in a video game whose contents are random and revealed only after purchase.
- Dark pattern
- An interface designed to steer people into choices they would not otherwise make, such as a subscription that is easy to start and hard to cancel.
Foundations
- There's No Such Thing as a Free Lunch: How Freebies and Credit Operate as Part of Rational Drug Market Activity
- Ross Coomber, 2003
- Shining a Light on Dark Patterns
- Jamie Luguri and Lior Jacob Strahilevitz, 2021
Related Notes
- The Metric That Ruins Everything
- Software teams track time on page, clicks, conversions, engagement, everything. Then someone picks the metric that matters. That's when things start breaking.
- The Two Stripes at Molineux
- In 1959 an East German army club painted over the third stripe on its Adidas boots rather than admit the socialist state made worse footwear. Sixty-seven years later, UEFA pays its top-ranked club thirty-six times what it pays its bottom one, by statute. A look at what concentrates the game.
- The Jockey and the Absurd
- A friend with betting slips in one hand and philosophy books in the other. Horse racing and existentialism both confront forces you cannot control.