The Burger That Benchmarks Everything
A cross-border sandwich index and regional software pricing are two instruments calibrated against an affordable market floor that has moved. When users acted honestly on regional pricing, the companies cracked down, turning a measurement into a gesture.
A monthly design subscription costs an identical number of dollars whether you’re in San Francisco or Sarajevo. The dollar, however, does not.
A famous economic index measures that gap by tracking a single standardized burger across borders. Same inputs, same labour, same process, reproduced reliably enough that the price difference between countries says something real about purchasing power that exchange rates alone don’t capture. Economists use it to find currencies that are quietly overvalued or quietly crushed.
The tech world has something similar, hiding in plain sight. Take the monthly cost of a standard suite of tools a working developer or designer actually needs. Version control, a prototyping tool, cloud compute, a communication platform, every line fixed in dollars because the companies that built them priced for one labour market and then sold everywhere else without adjustment.
Some companies noticed and introduced regional pricing. Lower tiers for lower-income markets, a single product available at fractions of its list cost depending on where the account was registered. A genuine attempt at purchasing power parity, or close enough.
Then the arbitrage started. Someone in London realized a VPN and a foreign billing address could cut an annual subscription by two-thirds. Forums filled with instructions, and the accommodation became a loophole, then a crackdown.
The crackdown is the interesting part. Regional pricing was doing exactly what the sandwich index measured, only in reverse, charging less where money was worth less. When users acted on that logic, the companies stopped offering it.
The burger has been drifting the same way from the other end. Fast food traffic has dropped by double digits among the people the chain was built for, while wealthier customers keep spending. The thing that was supposed to represent accessible, universal consumption no longer reaches the audience it was meant to represent.
Both instruments were calibrated against a market whose bottom sat low enough to measure from. The software version failed when anyone tried to use it honestly. The burger version failed because its original customer was priced out of lunch.
A benchmark that only works while nobody acts on it is not a benchmark. It is a souvenir of the market that used to exist.
Request an AI summary
Learn more about the ideas and references behind this note.
FAQ
- What is the Big Mac Index?
- An informal exchange-rate measure published by The Economist since 1986. It compares the price of the same standardized burger across countries to estimate whether currencies are under or overvalued against the US dollar. The point is to offer a readable stand-in for purchasing power parity, and to ask why a sandwich with identical inputs costs very different amounts in different places.
- Why do software companies use regional pricing?
- To match a product's price to what a given market can actually pay. Charging New York rates in Mumbai would price out most potential users, so companies offer discounted tiers based on where the account is registered. It's an attempt at purchasing power parity applied to subscriptions.
- Why did companies crack down on VPN-based pricing workarounds?
- Because regional pricing only works as an accommodation, not as open arbitrage. When users started spoofing their location via VPN to capture discounts meant for other markets, the gap between list price and regional price turned into a revenue leak. The discount windows tightened and the enforcement got louder.
- What are some related topics to explore?
- purchasing power paritybig mac indexregional software pricingsoftware subscription pricingvpn pricing arbitragecost of living benchmarks
Defined Terms
- Purchasing power parity
- The theory that exchange rates should adjust so the same goods cost the same amount across countries, meaning a dollar buys comparable value everywhere.
- Arbitrage
- Exploiting price differences between markets for profit, often by buying where something is cheap and selling, or qualifying, where it is expensive.
Foundations
- The Big Mac index
- The Economist, 1986
- Purchasing Power Parity
- After Gustav Cassel, 1918
Related Reading
Related Notes
- The Efficiency of Being Inefficient
- There's something odd about watching someone stand in front of a human being, staring at a screen to order coffee. The person behind the counter is right there. They could probably make the drink faster if you just asked. But we've been sold the idea that this is better, that the screen removes friction, and friction is apparently the enemy of a good Tuesday afternoon.
- The Memory We Become
- There's a peculiar inversion to consider in how we think about living. What if our true existence unfolds not in the present moment we're experiencing, but in the memories we craft for others to carry forward?